What has been said about AFI that hasn't been said already? Obviously many bad comments lately from the early AFI faithful about their new releases, but here we are with a classic Hardcore album: Black Sails in The Sunset.

This, to me, is un-comparable with other works from this band because this album is an amazing and creative piece of work. This is the album that clashes constantly with Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes (for me) because both albums are downright breathtakingly awesome. It has great fast and melodic tunes with slow songs such as Clove Smoke Catharsis (with Dexter Holland as guest vocalist), God Called In Sick, fast-paced songs such as Porphyria Cutanea Tarda, Exsanguition, Lower It (Vinyl only and you can tell there's a slight resemblance to No Reason) and my favorite The Prayer Position. The Prayer Position is melodic, hard and catchy as fuck! I really do recommend you to pick this up on vinyl for that extra song.

Although their newer albums are not as good as the classics, AFI will always remain to be my favorite band.

THROUGH OUR BLEEDING, WE ARE ONE!

obviously its a great album, AFI takes a unique and good aproach to every album. I haven't heard an afi song that was a let down. in my eyes you cant lose by buying this.

I have had this on Cd since it was released and decided to pick it up on vinyl. This is the best work from the best band ever. Great mix of the old EBHC and the more melodic side AFI has taken on. This is GREAT. If you don't have it, GET IT NOW!!!!!

Wow.

What a great album. I've had this for years now, but just got around to ordering the vinyl. This is my second favorite album of all time (my favorite being The Art Of Drowning.) This album is for people who enjoy great music. If anyone tells you AFI sucks, they are wrong and will always be wrong, and probably suck at living.

Whoa!! This is AFI's supreme album. In my opinion, this is their best release to date. (from what i hear, their new one is gonna be insane) People like Art of Drowning better, but i think this record has their best songs. Their is NOT one bad song on this, and that's rare. You can put this album on, and not skip over one song. So if you are listening to this, you better sit down, cause you can't start it and not finish it. It's just that good.

i liked the art of drowning for the most part, and it seems like all of the other reviews on here said it was sort of in the same vein, so i decided to give it a shot. i wish i hadn't. this is just a tad too cheese for me.