There is nothing quite like a Dinosaur Jr. album. The best ones are always recognizable from
the first notes. And even though J tries to trip us up by smearing “Don’t Pretend You Didn’t
Know” with keyboards, it’s clear from the moment he starts his vocals that this is the one and
only Dinosaur Jr., long reigning kings of Amherst, Massachusetts (and anywhere else they
choose to hang their toques).
I Bet on Sky is the third Dinosaur Jr. album since the original trio – J Mascis, Lou Barlow and
Murph – reformed in 2005. And, crazily, it marks the band’s 10th studio album since their
debut on Homestead Records in 1985. Back in the ‘80s, if anyone has suggested that these
guys would be performing and recording at such a high level 27 years later, they would have
been laughed out of the tree fort. The trio’s early shows were so full of sonic chaos, such a
weird blend of aggression and catatonia that we all assumed they would flame out fast. But
the joke was on us.
The trio has taken everything they’ve learned from the various projects they tackled over the
years, and poured it directly into their current mix. J’s guitar approaches some of its most
unhinged playing here, but there’s a sense of instrumental control that matches the sweet
murk of his vocals (not that he always remembers to exercise control on stage, but that’s
another milieu). This is head-bobbing riff-romance at the apex. Lou’s basswork shows a lot
more melodicism now as well, although his two songs on I Bet on Sky retain the jagged
rhythmic edge that has so often marked his work. And Murph…well, he still pounds the
drums as hard and as strong as a pro wrestler, with deceptively simple structures that manage
to interweave themselves perfectly with his bandmates’ melodic explosions.
After submerging myself in I Bet on Sky, it’s clear that the album is a true and worthy
addition to the Dinosaur Jr. discography. It hews close enough to rock formalism to please
the squares. Yet it is brilliantly imprinted with the trio’s magical equation, which is a gift to
the rest of us. For a combo that began as anomalous fusion of hardcore punk and pop
influences, Dinosaur Jr. have proven themselves to be unlikely masters of the long game.
Their new album is a triumph of both form and function. And it augurs well for their future
trajectory. If I were prone to wagering, I’d say their best days are yet ahead of them. And
yeah. I would bet the sky on it.