Almost four years in the making, Piñata by Chicago trio volcano! is
the long-awaited follow-up to the trio’s celebrated 2008 album Paperwork. Well worth the wait; by any measure it’s their best yet.
Piñata is the sound of volcano! past distilled into a most potent formula for the present: unsparingly concise, stickily melodic, lyrically
stranger, darkly humorous, ferociously driven, fabulously inventive.
Clocking in at just over 40 minutes, the album has an aggressive energy that’s as exciting as it is unpredictable. It’s leaner and meaner
than its predecessors, with the themes behind the songs drawn from
more familiar sources. “They’re mainly based on weird fantasies,”
says frontman Aaron With. “Our goal was to tell stories with strange
but universal sentiments.”
These fantasies are hardly commonplace musings on love and life.
“Child Star” imagines its protagonist (re)born with all the skills and
experience of a previous life, gaining competitive advantage over a
helpless peer group. “St. Mary of Nazareth” takes the listener on a tour
of a spaceship disguised as Catholic hospital, where the nurses are
nuns, and the nuns are aliens. Lead single “Piñata” is a petty vision of
posthumous karmic retribution, while “Fighter,” the album’s dramatic
centerpiece, is a violent revenge fantasy set to music. But while the
songs can be complex conceptually, the incisive compositions ensure
they effortlessly get under your skin.
It makes perfect sense that at the time of writing Piñata, volcano!
were indulging themselves on radio hits alongside a steady diet of
music from the outer reaches. Meanwhile the band has lost none of
the playful, idiosyncratic elements that make them unique. “We kept
the weird energy, the melodic tension, and the neurotic rhythm,” says
With, “but we’ve made the framework a little more decipherable.” Not
a second is wasted as volcano! gleefully take a baseball bat to musical
convention in the name of great pop.